Written Answer by Minister for Law, Mr K Shanmugam, to Parliamentary Question on Status of Writ of Seizure and Sale (WSS) Proceedings Currently on Hold

02 Nov 2020 Posted in Parliamentary speeches and responses

Mr Mohd Fahmi Bin Aliman (Member of Parliament for Marine Parade GRC)

Question
To ask the Minister for Law with regard to Writ of Seizure and Sale (WSS) proceedings for non-commercial cases that are currently on hold (a) what are the concerns that are holding back the WSS proceedings that have been paused at different stages; (b) what is the expected date of resumption for these WSS proceedings; and (c) what arrangements are in place to handle the backlog of cases accumulated since the circuit breaker period.

Written Answer:

1. We understand the question relating to “Writ of Seizure and Sale¹ (WSS) proceedings for non-commercial cases” to refer to cases where a WSS is issued for the seizure of movable property on premises used for non-commercial purposes or the premises of a non-commercial entity.

2. All enforcement actions, including WSS proceedings in non-commercial cases, were put on hold during the circuit breaker period from 7 April to 1 June 2020² in accordance with the COVID-19 (Temporary Measures) (Control Order) Regulations 2020 (“the Control Order Regulations”) in force at that time³.

3. Following the phased exit from the circuit breaker period, and the establishment of the necessary safe distancing and other applicable measures for the safe resumption of enforcement actions, WSS proceedings for non-commercial cases have resumed.

4. The Supreme Court and State Courts bailiffs have since completed execution of the seizure stage of all WSS proceedings for movable properties in non-commercial cases that accumulated during the circuit breaker period.

5. The next step in WSS proceedings is the sale of the seized movable properties, which is conducted via physical auctions. These are held at the premises where the movable properties were seized, to avoid incurring extra costs for transport and storage and to reduce the risk of damage.

6. These physical auctions are conducted by external auctioneers and typically involve more than 5 people – the auctioneer, the bailiff, potential bidders and the judgment creditors’ representative(s). Given the number of individuals involved, physical auctions for seized movable properties located at places of residence have been put on hold, in line with the Control Order Regulations⁴.

7. The courts will resume the auctions when such activities can be conducted safely in accordance with the Control Order Regulations.

^{1. The WSS is a legal mechanism available to judgment creditors to recover monies that are owed to the judgment creditor under a judgment or order of court. WSS proceedings entail (a) an application to court, (b) seizure of property of the judgment debtor by the court bailiff, and (c) the sale of the seized property with the proceeds being used to satisfy the judgment debt. ↩}

^{2. Supreme Court Registrar’s Circulars No. 4 and 5 of 2020 and State Courts’ Registrar’s Circulars No. 8 and 9 of 2020. ↩}

^{3. Regulation 4 of the Control Order Regulations required any judgment debtor to deny entry to persons who would ordinarily be involved in the process of seizing property – e.g. judgment creditor’s representatives or third parties such as auxiliary police officers or locksmiths.↩}

^{4. Regulation 4(4) of the Control Order Regulations.↩}

Last updated on 02 Nov 2020